Sign in or create a free account to save this Card to your Deck.
Activity Card · Where to look
Sensemaking
MORE DATA DOES NOT CREATE BETTER JUDGMENT BY ITSELF.
Sensemaking is the first Planning competency. It is the disciplined work of developing a useful interpretation of a situation before choosing direction. Leaders separate observations from assumptions, compare competing explanations, identify missing evidence, and ask what would disconfirm the story they currently prefer. AI can compress more information into view and surface patterns humans might miss, but it can also make a weak interpretation sound coherent. The leadership test is whether leaders can explain what they believe is happening, what remains uncertain, which alternatives still fit the evidence, and what decision the current understanding supports. Good sensemaking stays revisable when new evidence appears.
Expanded teaching
Expanded teaching
The leadership job
Sensemaking answers a question that comes before strategy: What is happening here, and what does it mean for us? Leaders rarely receive complete, clean, uncontested information. Customer behavior changes while internal metrics lag. Two capable executives can read the same data differently. A forecast can be numerically precise while resting on assumptions nobody has challenged. The job is to develop a sufficiently useful interpretation to guide the next decision without pretending uncertainty has disappeared. Sensemaking belongs in Planning because direction depends on interpretation. If the interpretation is weak, Organizational Steering can allocate resources decisively in the wrong direction and Stakeholder Alignment can create commitment around a mistaken story.
Separate evidence from the story about the evidence
A useful situation assessment distinguishes at least four things: what has been directly observed, what the team believes those observations mean, what remains unknown, and what decision is being considered. “Renewals fell 11 percent” is an observation. “Customers are becoming more price sensitive” is an interpretation. “A new competitor caused it” is a causal hypothesis. “We should cut price” is a proposed response. Each statement requires different evidence. This separation lets a leadership team see where disagreement is about the data, where it is about interpretation, and where it is about risk tolerance.
Compare competing interpretations
The first coherent explanation has an unfair advantage because it organizes the noise. Strong sensemaking deliberately creates competition for the preferred explanation. Ask: What else could explain the same pattern? What evidence would we expect to see if each explanation were true? What observation would make us change our mind? Which decision changes depending on which explanation is correct? The goal is to expose the assumptions that matter before the organization commits money, people, or reputation to them.
Evidence of competent Sensemaking
Look at an important recent leadership decision. Can the team reconstruct the evidence used, assumptions made, alternatives considered, and uncertainty that remained? Competent sensemaking is visible when leaders revise their view as evidence changes, distinguish signal from noise, and make decisions with explicit assumptions rather than hidden ones. More reports, dashboards, or AI-generated analysis do not by themselves demonstrate the capability.
Where AI belongs
AI is useful for organizing large bodies of permitted information, summarizing competing sources, comparing scenarios, surfacing anomalies, and generating questions that challenge an initial interpretation. It should not be treated as an authority that settles meaning. Leaders remain responsible for validating sources, deciding which uncertainty matters, engaging people who hold relevant context, and choosing what risk to act on.
First intervention and output
Choose one consequential decision and create a one-page Situation Brief: observations we can support; current interpretation; plausible alternatives; missing evidence that could change the decision; and the decision, owner, and next review point. Ask AI to challenge the interpretation and suggest disconfirming evidence, but require leaders to verify consequential claims.
Diagnostic inquiry
Questions to ask, not conclusions
When an important business signal changes, can your leadership team distinguish what it knows from what it assumes and compare credible alternative explanations before committing to action?
Questions that distinguish possible explanations
- What current leadership decision depends most heavily on an interpretation that has not been explicitly tested?
- Which piece of evidence would most strongly challenge the explanation your team currently prefers?
- When did your leadership team last change its interpretation because new evidence contradicted the original story?
Practical application
Practical application
Run a 60-minute Sensemaking Review on one current issue. Separate observations from interpretations, generate at least two plausible alternatives, identify missing or disconfirming evidence, then decide what can be acted on now, who owns the next step, and when the interpretation will be reviewed. Save the Situation Brief as the decision record.
Ask Atria
Talk through this Card
Talk it through with us
If this Card describes your week, a free conversation is the fastest way to see what it means for your company and what to do next.
Book a free conversation